Truck Insurance Rates Threaten U.S. Freight Sector Stability

The U.S. freight industry serves as a vital artery in the nation’s supply chain. Trucks move roughly 73% of the nation’s freight by weight, according to data from the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics. Truck drivers have faced mounting challenges since 2020.

First, it was a global supply chain disruption during the height of COVID. Then, they were hit with dropping freight rates amid rising inflation and an increase in cargo thefts that further stressed an already tight supply chain.

Now, truckers must confront their latest obstacle head-on – surging commercial trucking insurance rates. These escalating costs are hitting an industry already grappling with other pressures.

U.S. truck drivers can’t seem to catch a break.

What’s Driving the High Truck Driver Insurance Rates?

The steep rise in truck driver insurance premiums is largely driven by an increase in crash frequency and severity. An overall uptick in truck-involved crashes caused bodily injury costs to climb 40% between 2018 and 2022, the most recent years for crash data available. Insurance industry analysts expect another 7% growth in 2024.

Further complicating the matter are attorneys actively pursuing individuals hurt in truck crashes and encouraging them to file personal injury claims against drivers and trucking carriers. More claimants seeking legal representation results in higher rates of expenditure for medical procedures and treatments.

Plaintiff attorneys typically push for settlements that are an average of 37.7% higher than jury awards. States with more litigious environments such as California, Michigan, New Jersey, and North Carolina saw small verdict settlements balloon to between $406,386 to $449,792.

Other factors behind the rising costs include:

  • Economic conditions within the industry. Incurred losses of commercial vehicles have grown by 50% in recent years. The increase in losses, coupled with high claims severity, causes underwriting losses despite rising premiums.
  • Fleet size and sector. Insurance experts disagree on whether fleet size or safety record is more important. However, both factors, along with the specific sector or type of operation, significantly impact truck driver insurance rates.
  • Operational factors. The type of operations, freight values, and regions or states of operation play a critical role in determining truck insurance rates. Carriers operating in high-risk areas or transporting high-value cargo face higher premiums.
  • Safety records. A carrier’s safety record heavily influences commercial insurance premiums. Carriers with better safety performance can typically secure lower premiums. Consistent improvements in safety technology adoption, driver training, and hiring practices can contribute to less expensive rates.

The Cost of Replacement

Traveler’s Insurance – one of the largest commercial insurance companies – included vehicle repair and replacement costs as one of the primary reasons for higher truck insurance rates. Newer trucks outfitted with advanced materials and technology make driving more comfortable and safer – but also more expensive.

Vehicles aren’t the only items that may need replacing after an accident. Cargo damage can jack up the final tally of what an insurance company must pay.

How are High Truck Insurance Rates Impacting Drivers?

High truck insurance rates are impacting drivers at a time when they’re already struggling to keep their heads above the water.

Gamina Oliver, an owner-operator with a small fleet of three trucks, said she relocated her business from Illinois to Georgia in the hopes of securing lower annual insurance premiums. Because of the high insurance rates and other pressures impacting the industry, Oliver only operates one of her three trucks.

“My previous insurance was paid for the year when I left Illinois,” she said. “When I went to redo it in Georgia, my rates were almost double. Before I switched states, I was paying $1,223, which I thought was pretty high. When I renewed it in Georgia, I paid $2,223.”

Oliver said the way it works is insurance companies offer annual contracts with truck drivers and carriers that allow them to pay their premium for 10 months with a 2-month grace period to prepare for the start of the next insurance period.

“Before COVID, if you didn’t have any claims, you would get a small discount with your insurance company if you renewed your policy with them at the end of the year,” she said. “Not anymore. There’s no more discounts for keeping your insurance and not having any claims.”

Like many of her fellow owner-operators, Oliver continues to shop around in the hopes of finding lower rates. In the meantime, she said she’s noticing some commercial insurance companies have started offering month-to-month coverage, which is a possible money-saving solution for small owner-operators like herself. Some independent owner-operators park their trucks during slow periods and could drop their insurance coverage during those times if they had a month-to-month policy. “That way, we’re only paying for the months we’re actively driving,” she said.

In the meantime, Oliver said she doesn’t think commercial rates will stabilize until late 2025 at the earliest.

What are Some Strategies and Solutions for High Truck Insurance?

Going green can lower insurance premiums for commercial truck drivers. Individual owner-operators and fleet carriers that embrace eco-friendly practices can reduce their carbon footprints and enjoy savings in their annual insurance premiums.

Sustainable logistics often emphasizes fuel-efficient driving techniques such as maintaining steady speeds, minimizing idling, and avoiding rapid acceleration and braking. These habits save fuel and reduce the risk of accidents, leading to fewer claims and lower insurance premiums.

Advanced technology including telematics, GPS tracking, and real-time monitoring helps carriers track driver behavior, optimize routes, and prevent accidents. Commercial insurers may offer discounts for using this kind of technology because it demonstrates a commitment to safety.

2 thoughts on “Truck Insurance Rates Threaten U.S. Freight Sector Stability”

  1. Pingback: John
  2. In the past decade we have seen a continuous rise in accidents, and as a result, the insurance costs across the United States. Not only the frequency of claims but also their severity are increasing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What Our Customers Say About Us And Our Work

Jo-Ann Hill

I want to say thank you for your help in finding a warehouse so quickly. Your service was amazing. I received replies the same day and have selected a company that will work well for us. I definitely recommend your services.

Vee Zeniuk

I wanted to express my gratitude for your services and let you know that it was a very enjoyable experience! We have selected one of the companies and they are awesome!


You are doing such a great job and this service that you provide is a life saver for people especially startups like me....We cannot spend budgets on researching as much as the big firms can...and you provide us one stop solution which will answer all our questions.

Joyce Sloss

I just wanted to let you know that I selected one of your vendors as our fulfillment house. They can do what we need and we’re looking forward to working with them. They can handle our “special projects” fulfillment, which was key to our decision in bringing them onboard. I appreciate this service. It was great for our company.

Jeffrey Schmidt

I didn’t know there was so much difference in fulfillment companies — this was my first time in need of this sort of service. After a Google search I luckily stumbled upon They saved me an incredible amount of time and money. Within minutes I had a couple of emails from good companies that fit my situation. I am very appreciative of their help.

Eric Kolb

Warehousing and Fulfillment was the perfect matchmaker in finding us a fulfillment partner. They provided several great options, all of whom were very responsive and willing to take the time to talk through our needs. We ended up going with W&F’s top match and we couldn’t be happier. I highly recommend W&F, particularly to anyone whose business relies on a strong fulfillment partner.

Paul Sauer

We were having multiple issues with our 3PL fulfilling warranty replacement parts. Our company needed to make a change and make one fast. I reached out to to facilitate my search for a reputable, service oriented 3PL that can handle the demands of a highly seasonal business to pick, pack and ship parts quickly. I received several qualified 3PL leads that matched what we were looking for. After reviewing and speaking with many one stood out from the rest, and we found a great partner. We could not recommend enough.

Read More

Denis Mills

We found the perfect third-party fulfillment vendor through insightQuote. We never would have found them on our own. We can’t thank you enough and our customers thank you too.

Sarah De Munck

Thanks for all of your help. This was a huge undertaking for us and your guidance was extremely helpful!

Gwynne MacHattie

Thank you so much for your excellent service. We have chosen one to go forward with. This has saved us a great deal of time.

Ash Cook

They really listened to our requirements and then matched us with great vendors that could meet our specific challenges.

Corky Bless

I just wanted to say thank you so much for setting me up with these vendors. I have found pricing better than I ever expected to find.

Brian Chui

Legit, this was such a good experience ... I was shocked how fast the vendors contacted me and got the ball rolling. This was such a pleasant experience

Donald Willick

What an awesome service. A problem I fought with daily for over 3 weeks, solved in less than 24 hours.

warehousing and fulfillment arrow up