Outsourcing Warehousing & Fulfillment: Pros and Cons for Ecommerce and Retail Businesses

Why Ecommerce and Retail Businesses Consider Outsourcing Fulfillment

If you run an ecommerce brand, a direct-to-consumer startup, or sell products internationally, you depend on consistent order fulfillment. As your business grows, you’ll need to decide: manage warehousing in-house or outsource it to a third-party logistics (3PL) company?

This decision affects your costs, workload, and delivery speed.

This guide is for businesses that need to weigh both options. It explains what outsourcing involves, the benefits and drawbacks, and how to decide based on your order volume, budget, and priorities.

9 Signs It May Be Time to Outsource Fulfillment

Here are signs that working with a fulfillment provider could be worth considering:

• Other work is getting delayed. If warehousing tasks take most of your time, marketing, product development, or sales may stall. Outsourcing can help you redirect your focus.
• Order volume exceeds capacity. If orders are late or you can’t keep up with demand, a 3PL may have the space and labor to handle the increase.
• Returns processing is inefficient. Handling returns requires staff, software, and processes. If returns take too long or disrupt other operations, outsourcing can address this.
• More shipping errors or customer complaints. Mistakes in picking and packing can lead to unhappy customers. A fulfillment provider may have established procedures that reduce errors.
• You’re running out of space or staff. If you’re considering leasing more warehouse space or hiring more employees but don’t want the overhead, outsourcing is an alternative.
• Shipping costs are higher than necessary. 3PLs often have negotiated carrier rates that can be lower than what you can get on your own.
• Inventory tracking is inconsistent. Accurate inventory counts are essential. If you can’t maintain them, a 3PL with established inventory systems may help.
• Vendor coordination is difficult. If you have multiple suppliers and limited time to track shipments, some 3PLs can help manage inbound deliveries.
• You want to add new services or move into new areas. If you plan to offer faster shipping or custom packaging but can’t do it internally, outsourcing may provide these options without major investments.

What Managing Fulfillment In-House Involves

Handling your own in-house fulfillment means controlling storage, staffing, and shipping. It also comes with ongoing responsibilities and costs. If you’re considering an in-house operation, think through these questions:

• Warehouse space: How much space will you need to handle orders now and during busy periods?
• Hiring: How many employees will you need for picking, packing, supervision, and customer service?
• Location: Can you find a location that balances rent costs with shipping speed to customers?
• Systems: What inventory management software will you use, and who will maintain it?
• Insurance: What insurance policies will you need to cover inventory and employees?
• Administrative tasks: Who will track inventory, manage vendors, and oversee warehouse operations?

Running fulfillment internally can work if you have steady order volume, enough staff, and the budget for equipment and software. If not, it may be harder to scale.

Pros and Cons of Outsourcing Fulfillment

Outsourcing has clear advantages:

• Capacity that adjusts as you grow: You can pay for storage and labor as needed, without committing to a long-term lease or permanent staff.
• Potential for lower costs: 3PLs often negotiate better shipping rates and buy supplies in bulk. This can reduce your per-order costs.
• Less management time: Outsourcing allows you to delegate daily operations and focus on sales or product development.
• Access to established processes: 3PLs use warehouse management systems and trained teams, reducing setup time.
• Scalability: You can increase or decrease inventory without major disruptions.
• Multiple locations: Some providers have warehouses in different regions. This can shorten delivery times.
  Cons of Outsourcing Fulfillment

There are also drawbacks:

• Less direct oversight: You rely on the provider to manage your inventory and meet performance targets.
• Communication delays: Resolving an issue may take longer because you must coordinate with the provider’s team.
• Dependence on another company: If your provider has operational issues, it can impact your orders.
• Inventory off-site: You can’t inspect products in person without traveling to the warehouse.
• Issue resolution can take longer: Fixing packing or shipping problems may require multiple contacts.
• Quality control: Your standards depend on the provider’s training and processes.
• Not always cost-effective for low volume: If you ship small quantities, minimum fees may exceed the cost of in-house fulfillment. However, there are some great start-up friendly fulfillment companies.

Comparing Costs of Outsourcing Fulfillment

When you compare fulfillment costs, list all expenses for each option:

Outsourced Fulfillment:

• Receiving and storage fees (per pallet or cubic foot)
• Pick and pack fees per order
• Storage by the pallet, cubic foot, or bin
• Shipping costs (often discounted)
• Extra charges for returns or special services

In-House Fulfillment:

• Rent or mortgage for the facility
• Utilities and insurance
• Salaries and benefits
• Equipment and maintenance
• Software licenses
• Time spent managing operations

In-house costs are mostly fixed. Outsourced warehousing costs vary with your order volume and space needs.

How to Decide Whether to use an Outsourced Warehousing Service

To decide which approach works best:

• Review your current order volume and future projections.
• Assess your budget for warehousing, staff, and systems.
• Consider whether you prefer hands-on control or fewer management tasks.
• Identify any services you need (faster shipping, custom packaging) that a 3PL can offer.

Some businesses start in-house, then outsource as orders grow. Others use a mix, handling some orders internally and outsourcing the rest. And there are still plenty that manage complete in-house operations.

We’ll Help You Find the Right Outsourced Fulfillment Partner

If you’re searching for a fulfillment center that aligns with your specificneeds, WarehousingAndFulfillment.com is here to help. We match brands with pre-vetted warehousing and fulfillment providers based on your inventory, packaging, order volume, and location requirements.

Our matching service is completely free. We collect your needs and connect you with qualified 3PLs who already fit your criteria—saving you time and helping you avoid costly mismatches. You can ask questions, review their capabilities, and compare multiple quotes. Just fill out a quick form or give us a call to get started.

FAQs about Outsourced Fulfillment

What is outsourced fulfillment?

Hiring a third-party company to store, pack, and ship your orders.

What services do fulfillment companies offer?

They handle inventory storage, order processing, packing, shipping, and returns. Some also provide custom packaging or kitting.

Why wouldn’t a business outsource fulfillment?

You might prefer more control over inventory, or your order volume may be too low to offset minimum fees. Some companies have in-house processes that meet their needs effectively.

Last Step

Since 2005 We’ve Been Helping Companies Just Like Yours

Your contact information is held in the strictest of confidence. We will contact you before we connect you with vendors so that we can learn about your situation, obtain any of your contact preferences, and answer any of your questions.

YOU have control over your contact details:

• No unwanted contacts – you control how vendors respond to you
• Remain confidential if you wish
• No commitment to choose any of our vendors
• Ask our Fulfillment experts any questions you have!