Red Stag Reviews and Ratings

About Red Stag Fulfillment

Red Stag Fulfillment is a third-party logistics (3PL) provider specializing in eCommerce fulfillment. The company was founded after an eCommerce business outgrew two fulfillment providers, leading to the creation of Red Stag with a focus on inventory accuracy, fast shipping, and secure storage.

Red Stag primarily serves businesses with oversized, high-value, or fragile products, offering same-day fulfillment, high-security warehousing, and performance guarantees. It has a zero shrinkage policy, meaning businesses are reimbursed for lost or damaged inventory.

While Red Stag’s service quality and fulfillment guarantees are well-regarded, its reliance on FedEx, limited warehouse network, and pricing structure may not fit businesses with high-volume, low-margin products.

Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths

• Specialized Fulfillment – Supports oversized, high-value, and fragile products with handling tailored to these items.
• Fast Delivery Network – Two warehouse locations allow for 1-2 day shipping to most U.S. customers.
• Zero Shrinkage Policy – Compensates clients for lost or damaged inventory, a rare practice in fulfillment.
• Secure Warehousing – 24/7 security, video monitoring, and fraud prevention measures in place.
• No Long-Term Contracts – Flexible month-to-month agreements.

Weaknesses

• FedEx-Only Carrier Discounts – Limits shipping flexibility compared to providers with multiple carrier options.
• Not Cost-Effective for Small, Low-Cost Products – Higher fulfillment fees make it less viable for high-volume, low-margin businesses.
• Limited Warehouse Network – Only two locations may result in higher shipping costs for some businesses.

Pricing Breakdown

Red Stag’s pricing is structured around handling quality and fulfillment guarantees rather than low-cost fulfillment. Common fees include:

• Receiving Fees – $13.25 per pallet.
• Storage Fees – $2 per bin or $15 per pallet per month.
• Pick & Pack Fees – $2.25 to $2.65 for the first item, plus $0.30 per additional item.
• Shipping Costs – Carrier-based rates (FedEx discounts available).
• No Setup or SKU Fees – Unlike some 3PLs, no additional charges for account setup or SKU management.

The cost structure benefits businesses shipping large, high-value products but may not be the best fit for companies with low-cost, high-volume items.

Facility Locations

Red Stag operates two fulfillment centers in the U.S.:

• Knoxville, Tennessee
• Salt Lake City, Utah

This network supports 1-2 day shipping across most of the U.S., but businesses looking for greater warehouse distribution to optimize shipping costs may need a provider with a larger network.

Service Offerings

Order Fulfillment & Inventory Management

• Pick & Pack Fulfillment – Supports D2C, subscription boxes, and specialty products.
• Returns Processing – Managed in-house for faster restocking and reduced return costs.
• Inventory Tracking – Real-time order visibility with cloud-based inventory software.

Specialized & Value-Added Services

• Heavy & Oversized Product Handling – Designed for furniture, fitness equipment, and other bulky items.
• High-Security Warehousing – Video surveillance and security controls.
• Custom Packaging & Kitting – Branded packaging and custom order assembly available.

Technology & Integrations

• Cloud-Based Dashboard – Businesses can track orders, view inventory levels, and monitor fulfillment in real-time.
• eCommerce Platform Compatibility – Integrates with Shopify, WooCommerce, Amazon, and other major platforms.

While Red Stag’s fulfillment model prioritizes accuracy and security, the lack of multi-carrier shipping options and limited warehouse locations could be drawbacks for businesses needing broader shipping flexibility.

Service Considerations

• Limited Carrier Selection – FedEx-only discounts limit shipping flexibility compared to providers offering UPS, USPS, and regional carriers.
• Higher Pricing for High-Volume, Low-Margin Products – Fulfillment fees favor businesses shipping large, expensive items.
• Smaller Warehouse Network – Only two locations, making nationwide distribution less cost-effective for some businesses.

Businesses shipping specialty products with strict handling requirements may find Red Stag a good fit, while brands needing greater carrier flexibility and warehouse coverage should weigh other options.

Customer Feedback

Positive Reviews:

• Reliable service with low error rates.
• Accurate inventory tracking and order fulfillment.
• Strong customer service and communication.

Common Complaints:

• Shipping limited to FedEx.
• Higher costs for businesses with small, inexpensive products.
• Limited number of fulfillment centers.

Review Scores:

• Glassdoor: 3.2/5 stars.
• Google Reviews: 4.3/5 stars.

Reviews are mostly positive, but the low total number of reviews makes long-term service consistency harder to evaluate.

Red Stag Fulfillment vs. WarehousingAndFulfillment.com

Red Stag Fulfillment Summary

Red Stag is best suited for businesses with large, high-value products that require secure handling and fast delivery. However, its FedEx-only shipping model, higher costs for small products, and limited warehouse network may not work for all eCommerce brands.

How WarehousingAndFulfillment.com Operates

WarehousingAndFulfillment.com helps businesses find fulfillment providers tailored to their needs. Instead of relying on a single 3PL, businesses are matched with providers based on order volume, shipping needs, and pricing structure.

Key Advantages:

• Flexible Carrier & Pricing Options – Businesses can work with multiple shipping carriers for cost savings.
• Expanded Fulfillment Network – More warehouse locations help lower shipping costs and improve delivery speed.
• Scalability for Growth – Custom fulfillment solutions for startups to enterprise brands.
• Vetted Providers – Providers are screened for reliability, pricing transparency, and performance.

Instead of a one-size-fits-all approach, WarehousingAndFulfillment.com helps businesses connect with the right fulfillment partner for their specific needs.

Red Stag Fulfillment provides accurate, high-security fulfillment with strong service guarantees, making it a good fit for oversized and fragile products. However, limited carrier options, a smaller warehouse network, and higher fees for small products may lead businesses to explore alternatives.

For businesses looking for a fulfillment provider with more carrier options, pricing flexibility, and broader warehouse distribution, WarehousingAndFulfillment.com offers a more adaptable and scalable solution.

To compare fulfillment providers and find the best fit, contact WarehousingAndFulfillment.com for free provider matching and pricing insights.

Last Step

Since 2005 We’ve Been Helping Companies Just Like Yours

Your contact information is held in the strictest of confidence. We will contact you before we connect you with vendors so that we can learn about your situation, obtain any of your contact preferences, and answer any of your questions.

YOU have control over your contact details:

• No unwanted contacts – you control how vendors respond to you
• Remain confidential if you wish
• No commitment to choose any of our vendors
• Ask our Fulfillment experts any questions you have!